Bernard Herrmann
Think of the scariest, most iconic two notes in cinema history. No, not the shark—the shrieking violin screech from the shower scene in Psycho. Alfred Hitchcock originally wanted absolute silence for that sequence. Bernard Herrmann told him he was an idiot (politely, or perhaps not so politely, as Herrmann was famously abrasive), wrote the cue anyway, and Hitchcock had the rare humility to double his salary. That cue alone fundamentally altered film scoring forever.
Born Max Herman in New York City to Russian-Jewish immigrants, Herrmann grew up immersed in the Lower East Side and steeped in classical music. He studied at Juilliard, worked closely with Orson Welles on The War of the Worlds broadcast and Citizen Kane, and then went on to score basically every suspense masterpiece that ever kept you awake at night, ending his career with Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver.
Herrmann had zero tolerance for studio meddling, pop music tie-ins, or foolish directors, which earned him a reputation as cinema's grumpiest genius. As for his Jewishness, while he wasn't particularly devout in the synagogue-going sense, his heritage was never in question. When you provide the soundtrack to the twentieth century's greatest neuroses, the kvell factor takes care of itself.