Betty Cuthbert
First off, let's clear up a minor geopolitical mix-up: Betty Cuthbert was not American. She was about as Australian as a kangaroo eating Vegemite in a eucalyptus tree. Dubbed the "Golden Girl" of Australian athletics, Cuthbert stormed the 1956 Melbourne Olympics as an eighteen-year-old, bagging gold in the 100 meters, 200 meters, and the 4x100 relay. Eight years later, after coming out of retirement, she added the inaugural 400-meter gold in Tokyo, cementing her status as one of track and field's absolute all-time greats.
So, why are we talking about her here? Well, people hear an old-timey name or see someone running unusually fast in the 1950s and start wondering. Maybe there's a Jewish grandparent hiding behind the surname Cuthbert?
Alas, no. Cuthbert is an ancient Anglo-Saxon name derived from Saint Cuthbert of Northumbria, which is about as far from the shtetl as humanly possible. Betty was born in Sydney to nursery owners Leslie and Marion Cuthbert, was a devout Protestant, and later in life became an outspoken born-again Christian who credited God with giving her the strength to battle multiple sclerosis.
An extraordinary athlete, an Australian national treasure, and an Olympic legend. But as far as the tribe is concerned? Strictly a spectator.