Carlos Reutemann
Formula One is not exactly teeming with Jewish drivers. Aside from Jody Scheckter, who clinched the 1979 championship for Ferrari and South Africa, the historical grid looks pretty gentile. So whenever a name with a vaguely Germanic ring appears on the podium—like Carlos Reutemann, who famously drove for Brabham, Ferrari, Lotus, and Williams—ears in the community perk up. Add in the fact that he hailed from Argentina, home to South America's largest Jewish population, and you have all the ingredients for wishful pedigree-hunting.
Alas, Carlos Alberto Reutemann was not Jewish. His father, Enrique Reutemann, was of Swiss-German descent, and his mother, Flora Molina, was of Italian and Spanish ancestry. Raised on a cattle ranch in Santa Fe, young Carlos grew up Catholic, developed a passion for fast machinery, and went on to win 12 Grands Prix, finishing as the 1981 World Drivers' Championship runner-up by a single, agonizing point to Nelson Piquet.
After hanging up his helmet, "El Lole" transitioned smoothly into Argentine politics, serving two terms as Governor of Santa Fe and spending over two decades in the National Senate. Along the way, he was a staunch, pragmatic Peronist who maintained warm relations with local Jewish institutions and unequivocally supported the investigation into the 1994 AMIA bombing, but purely as a conscientious statesman.
So while Argentina has given the world plenty of Jewish pride—and a handful of decent athletes—their most decorated modern racing driver remains entirely Swiss-Italian-Argentine Catholic. We'll just have to keep clinging to Scheckter.