Clas Thunberg
First, a minor geographical correction: Clas Thunberg was not Norwegian. He was Finnish. Yes, Finland, the land of saunas, brooding silence, and Paavo Nurmi. In fact, Thunberg was so dominant on the ice in the 1920s that people called him "the Nurmi of the ice," which was the highest possible compliment you could pay an endurance athlete at the time unless you wanted to call him "the guy who actually beats Nurmi."
Thunberg was a late bloomer by athletic standards, smoking and drinking his way through youth until he decided, around age 18, to get serious about strapping steel blades to his boots. It paid off: between the 1924 Chamonix Games and the 1928 St. Moritz Games, Thunberg skated away with five Olympic gold medals, a silver, a bronze, and multiple world championships. Five Olympic golds makes him one of the most decorated winter Olympians of all time.
So, what about the name? "Thunberg" sounds like it could maybe, in a very dim room if you squint hard enough, have some distant Germanic or Ashkenazi tilt. Alas, no. It’s thoroughly Nordic (Swedish-Finnish), just like Greta Thunberg, with whom he shares a surname and an utter lack of Jewish heritage. Clas was Lutheran through and through, or at least as Lutheran as an early 20th-century speed skater who loved tobacco and booze could manage to be.
No bar mitzvah, no pastrami, no Jewish roots whatsoever. Just Finnish grit and sharp blades. We respect the five gold medals, but we can't claim him.