C. H. O'D. Alexander
Look at that name: Conel Hugh O'Donel Alexander. If that doesn't scream Ulster Protestant with a pedigree trace going straight back to Irish gentry, nothing will. Despite being born in Cork, Ireland (wait, someone told you he was Polish? Who told you that? Polish? Conel Hugh O'Donel?! He was born in Cork, Ireland, to a professor of engineering!), he was as Anglo-Irish as they come.
Yet, Alexander lived a life that feels like it belongs in the quintessential Jewish intellectual hall of fame: supreme chess talent and world-saving cryptanalysis. During World War II, Alexander was recruited to Bletchley Park, where he worked in Hut 8 breaking the German Naval Enigma machine. In fact, he took over as head of Hut 8 after Alan Turing, proving to be far more adept at the administrative and human side of running a codebreaking unit than Turing ever was.
When he wasn't cracking Nazi naval ciphers, he was twice winning the British Chess Championship, earning the title of International Master (and later Grandmaster for correspondence chess), and beating world-class grandmasters like Max Euwe and David Bronstein. He eventually headed the cryptanalysis division at GCHQ for decades.
So while Alexander had the chess chops, the mathematical genius, and the secret-agent puzzle-solving brilliance that we'd love to claim, there isn't a drop of Jewish blood to be found. Just a lot of Irish, a dash of tea, and a whole lot of Enigma.