Frankie Frisch

Frankie Frisch, born Frank Francis Frisch, was a star second baseman and manager whose name, much like his speed on the bases, often caused people to jump to conclusions. Specifically, the conclusion that he was Jewish. This persistent rumor, likely fueled by his surname and the common perception of New York-born athletes, followed him throughout his illustrious career, and beyond.

However, a quick glance at the historical record reveals Frisch was not, in fact, "one of us." He was born and raised Catholic in the Bronx, attending Fordham University before embarking on a career that included World Series titles with both the New York Giants and the St. Louis Cardinals. So, while his baseball prowess was undeniable, his ancestral ties to the chosen people were, shall we say, non-existent.

Thus, "The Old Roman" (another nickname, decidedly less misleading) remains a celebrated figure in baseball history, albeit one who caused countless fans and Jewish grandmothers to wonder, "Is he one of ours?" The answer, dear readers, is a resounding and definitive "nope."