Glenn Davis
Not to be confused with Army's "Mr. Outside" Heisman winner of the exact same name, this Glenn Davis was the Ohio track phenom who ruled the 400-meter hurdles like few before or since. In 1956 and 1960, Davis snagged back-to-back Olympic gold medals in the event, threw in another gold in the 4x400 relay in Rome, and then decided to cap off his athletic resume by playing wide receiver for the Detroit Lions.
If running, jumping over obstacles at breakneck speed, and getting crushed by NFL linebackers sounds like the opposite of a traditional Jewish upbringing, you'd be right. Davis was born in Wellsburg, West Virginia, and grew up in Barberton, Ohio, with completely non-Jewish Midwestern roots.
So why even bother checking? Perhaps someone hoped a legendary hurdler named Davis might harbor a tiny drop of Tribe blood, allowing us to claim Olympic hardware outside of fencing and swimming. Alas, no such luck. Glenn Davis was just an exceptionally fast, thoroughly gentile American athletic marvel.