Guillermo Vilas
Before tennis had Rafael Nadal grunting and sliding across European clay, it had Guillermo Vilas: long mane flowing, headband tightly secured, left arm churning out topspin that made opponents contemplate early retirement. In 1977, Vilas went on a ridiculous tear, winning 16 ATP singles titles, including both Roland Garros and the US Open, while pioneering the between-the-legs trick shot he dubbed "the Gran Willy."
Naturally, in the grand tradition of confusing prominent Argentines or guys with flowing dark locks with members of the tribe, people sometimes wonder. Argentina has a sizable Jewish population, after all. But Vilas is about as standard-issue Argentine-Catholic as mate and beef ribs. Born in Buenos Aires to Roque José Vilas and Maruxa Rama, his family tree bears no connection to Abraham, Isaac, or Jacob.
So, if you were hoping to claim Vilas for your fantasy Jewish tennis league alongside Brad Gilbert and Harold Solomon, you're out of luck. The Gran Willy belongs entirely to Argentina.