Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Hal Newhouser
NotaJew
Profile №f7ba98

Hal Newhouser

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

When you look at the 1940s Detroit Tigers roster and spot a dominating Hall of Famer who threw blistering fastballs and carried the surname Newhouser, you might pause. Could "Prince Hal" be another member of the illustrious fraternity of mid-century Jewish baseball gods alongside his teammate Hank Greenberg? Alas, baseball fans, put away the Manischewitz.

Born Harold Newhouser in Detroit, Hal was the son of Czech-Polish immigrants and raised a devout Catholic. He attended St. Hedwig High School and grew up hurling fastballs rather than memorizing a Torah portion. His German-sounding surname certainly led to some mistaken assumptions over the decades, but there wasn't a single shred of Yiddishkeit in his dugout.

Still, what a pitcher he was. Newhouser remains the only pitcher in Major League history to win consecutive MVP awards (1944 and 1945), racking up 207 wins, an ERA title or two, and a World Series ring before later finding Derek Jeter as an Astros scout. Greenberg loved him, Detroit adored him, and Cooperstown eventually came calling.

He was brilliant, competitive, and entirely gentile. For Tigers-loving MOTs, Hank Greenberg and Al Kaline will just have to carry the load.

Filed October 31, 2026 · athletes

See Also