Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Hanns Eisler
BorderlineJew
Profile №d34aec

Hanns Eisler

Verdict: Borderline Jew
I · O · K Score
1
I
3
O
3
K
0 / 15

Wait, isn't that Kurt Weill? No, Weill was the guy who wrote "Mack the Knife" and fled Nazi Germany for Broadway. Hanns Eisler was the other German-Jewish, Brecht-collaborating, Nazi-fleeing composer—the one who chose the redder pill. While Weill was busy charming American theatergoers, Eisler was writing revolutionary proletarian anthems and buddying up with Hollywood leftists until the House Un-American Activities Committee decided he was the "Karl Marx of communism in the musical field." (Which, to be fair, was probably the greatest compliment HUAC ever paid a composer).

Eisler's father was Rudolf Eisler, an Austrian-Jewish philosopher; his mother was Lutheran. Hanns himself had zero interest in the synagogue, trading ancient Jewish scripture for Das Kapital at an early age. Yet when the Nazis took over, Eisler's Jewish lineage—not to mention his unrepentant Marxism—made his music "degenerate" and his presence in Germany decidedly non-viable. He fled, landed in California, snagged a couple of Oscar nominations, and then was booted out of the United States in 1948 during the Red Scare. Charlie Chaplin and Albert Einstein protested his deportation, which is quite the reference list.

Where did Eisler go after being kicked out by Uncle Sam? East Germany, naturally, where he wrote the country's national anthem, "Auferstanden aus Ruinen." But because irony is never in short supply behind the Iron Curtain, the East German authorities eventually banned the lyrics of his anthem because they mentioned a "united fatherland," which became politically inconvenient when the Berlin Wall went up.

So what do we have? A brilliant, thorny, half-Jewish modernist composer who gave up Schoenberg's twelve-tone technique to write tunes for the workers' movement, got hounded across two continents, and left behind a bizarre legacy spanning Hollywood film scores, avant-garde lieder, and a defunct communist anthem. You couldn't make him up if you tried.

Filed November 1, 2026 · musicians

See Also