Ian Thorpe
Before Michael Phelps became a terrifying aquatic harvesting machine, there was Ian Thorpe. The "Thorpedo" was the undisputed king of the pool at the turn of the millennium, bagging five Olympic gold medals, setting 13 individual long-course world records, and making the 400-meter freestyle look like a casual Sunday bath. Australia treated him like a demigod, and rightly so—he was practically half man, half flipper, with size 17 feet that could double as paddleboards.
Naturally, whenever an athlete achieves aquatic supremacy, we wonder if there's an echo of Mark Spitz lurking somewhere in the gene pool. Could the greatest middle-distance swimmer of his era be a Member of the Tribe? Alas, no. Thorpe was born in Sydney to Ken and Margaret Thorpe, a thoroughly Australian couple of British descent. His father played cricket, his mother played netball, and the family heritage is about as Anglican and Scottish/English as Vegemite on toast.
So while Thorpe remains a national treasure Down Under and a trailblazing icon in retirement, he offers zero kvell potential to the Jewish sports hall of fame. We will always have Mark Spitz and Lenny Krayzelburg, but the Thorpedo swims entirely in non-Jewish waters.