Jim Ryun
Before he was losing congressional seats in Kansas, Jim Ryun was breaking records and hearts on the track. In the mid-1960s, while still a high school kid in Wichita, Ryun became the first prep athlete to run a sub-four-minute mile, eventually clocking a legendary 3:55.3. He held world records, took home a silver medal in the 1500 meters at the 1968 Mexico City Olympics, and appeared on the cover of Sports Illustrated more times than most supermodels. If Jews had a tradition of producing world-record middle-distance track stars, Ryun would be a secular saint.
Alas, Jews generally prefer walking briskly to the buffet or power-walking through the mall to shaving tenths of a second off the 1500-meter dash in track spikes. Ryun is not Jewish. In fact, he's about as far from it as one can get: a devout, born-again evangelical Christian whose post-running career saw him serve five terms in the U.S. House of Representatives as a hardline social conservative.
Ryun's political tenure was marked by a strict adherence to religious right orthodoxy, completely devoid of any hidden bar mitzvah photos or covert lox consumption. He was eventually ousted by Democrat Nancy Boyda in 2006, ending a political run far less graceful than his athletic ones. A bona fide legend on the track, sure, but not our tribe's legend.