Jimmie Foxx
Jimmie Foxx, born James Emory Foxx, certainly earned his nickname "Double XX" for hitting lots of those. "The Beast" was another moniker, though not one we'd apply to his gefilte fish consumption. His career, spanning from 1925 to 1945, saw him belt 534 home runs and drive in nearly 2,000 runs, making him one of the sport's all-time greats.
While his career numbers were undeniably kvell-worthy, particularly his triple-crown season in 1933, any connection to the Chosen People seems to be as elusive as a truly affordable pastrami on rye these days. There's no indication in his biographical information or any historical records that Jimmie Foxx had even a passing acquaintance with a menorah, let alone davening.
So, while we appreciate his formidable talent and the way he struck fear into pitchers' hearts, we're going to have to chalk this one up as a swing and a miss for Team Oy Vey. He may have been a beast on the field, but off it, he was just a regular guy from Maryland, and not a member of the tribe.