Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №8612ab

John Hiller

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

Baseball fans of a certain vintage remember John Hiller as a hero of the bullpen and a walking miracle. Born in Toronto, Ontario (making him Canadian, not American, despite what casual stadium chatter might claim), Hiller spent his entire 15-season major league career with the Detroit Tigers. In 1971, at just 27 years old, he suffered a massive heart attack, lost an intestinal tract of weight, underwent surgery, and was told he'd never pitch again. Instead, he returned to the mound in 1972, saved 38 games in 1973—a major league record at the time—and snagged the AL Fireman of the Year award.

Naturally, whenever a gutsy southpaw named "Hiller" dominates the diamond, the ears of Jewish baseball trivia buffs perk up. After all, "Hiller" sounds German enough, and perhaps there was a bar mitzvah tucked away somewhere between Ontario and Tiger Stadium. We've certainly combed through thinner rosters looking for tribe members.

Alas, no such luck. Hiller is of German and Canadian descent, but strictly of the Gentile variety. No menorahs, no secret matzah, just a hard-throwing Canadian kid who refused to let cardiovascular disaster stop him from mowing down American League hitters.

So while we tip our cap to one of the greatest comeback stories in baseball history, we can't claim him for the minyan. You'll just have to settle for Sandy Koufax and Ken Holtzman like the rest of us.

Filed October 30, 2026 · athletes

See Also