Johnny Vander Meer
Throwing a no-hitter in Major League Baseball is one of the hardest feats in all of professional sports. Doing it twice in a row is statistically bordering on impossible. Yet in June 1938, a 23-year-old Cincinnati Reds southpaw named Johnny Vander Meer did just that, shutting down the Boston Bees and then the Brooklyn Dodgers without surrendering a single hit. Decades later, his record stands alongside Joe DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak as one of baseball's unbreakable benchmarks.
Naturally, whenever an athlete accomplishes something legendary under a vaguely Germanic-sounding surname, Jewish sports enthusiasts lean forward and adjust their glasses. Could Vander Meer be one of ours? After all, baseball history has Sandy Koufax, Ken Holtzman, and Shawn Green. What's one more arm in the mythical Jewish rotation?
Alas, no dice. Vander Meer was the son of Jacob and Lucretia Vander Meer, Dutch immigrants who settled in New Jersey and were thoroughly, unmistakably Calvinist Dutch, not Jewish. His ancestors came from the canals and tulip fields of the Netherlands, not the shtetls of Eastern Europe.
So while baseball fans will forever marvel at Johnny Vander Meer's lightning-in-a-bottle summer of 1938, the Tribe cannot claim his singular spot in the record books. We'll just have to settle for Koufax's four no-nos and three Cy Youngs instead.