Margery Hinton
Wait, American Olympic gold medalist? Let's pump the brakes on the star-spangled banner. Margery Hinton was, in fact, thoroughly British. Born in Manchester, she made waves as a teenage breaststroke phenom, competing for Great Britain at the 1928, 1932, and 1936 Summer Olympics. In Amsterdam in 1928, she was just 13 years old—one of the youngest Olympians in British history.
Did she win a gold medal? Not at the Olympics, no. She captured a bronze at the 1938 European Championships and collected plenty of medals representing England at the British Empire Games, but an Olympic gold was not in the cards. Nor was water polo on the women's Olympic program back then, though she was an avid swimmer through and through.
More importantly for our purposes, what about the Jewish angle? Hinton is as classic an English surname as they come, and Margery was born into an ordinary Mancunian family with zero ties to the Tribe. No Jewish heritage, no synagogue attendance, not even a pastrami sandwich on the side.
So while she deserves full credit for being a pioneering, three-time Olympian who swam circles around the competition before she was old enough to drive, she'll have to settle for the British sports history books rather than the annals of Jewish athletic pride.