Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №a1ae23

Mel Ott

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

Mel Ott spent twenty-two seasons with the New York Giants, clobbering 511 home runs with an unorthodox batting stance that involved lifting his right foot high in the air before swinging. Playing in a city overflowing with Jewish immigrants and their baseball-crazed kids, the 5-foot-9 slugger was beloved across the five boroughs. And with a name like \"Mel Ott\"—short, snappy, and sounding like someone's uncle from Flatbush—it seemed only natural that local fans quietly adopted him as one of their own.

Alas, wishful thinking does not a member of the Tribe make. Melvin Thomas Ott was born in Gretna, Louisiana, to Charles and Christine Ott, proud descendants of Catholic immigrants from Alsace-Lorraine and Germany. He was raised strictly Roman Catholic, attended Catholic schools, and never stepped foot in a synagogue except perhaps in the collective imagination of delirious Polo Grounds bleacher bums who desperately wanted an alternative to Hank Greenberg.

Ott's reputation as a decent guy was legendary—he was famously the subject of manager Leo Durocher's quip, \"Nice guys finish last\" (Durocher later clarified he meant Ott was too nice to be a cutthroat manager). A Hall of Famer, a World Series champion, and a bona fide baseball icon. But as for Jewish heritage? Not even a drop.

Filed October 29, 2026 · athletes

See Also