Mike Lowell
First off, let us clear up some baseball fundamentals: Mike Lowell was never a pitcher. He was a slick-fielding, clutch-hitting third baseman who won World Series rings with both the Florida Marlins and the Boston Red Sox, capturing the 2007 World Series MVP trophy in the process. He did, however, face down testicular cancer early in his career and return to play at an elite level, so the man deserves all the respect he can get—even if he never threw a single inning of relief.
Born in Puerto Rico to Cuban parents, Lowell's surname often raises eyebrows among those expecting a Martinez or a Hernandez. The name comes from his paternal grandfather, but it's pure Anglo-Saxon, not Ashkenazi. Despite wishful thinking from Red Sox fans hoping Kevin Youkilis had another Member of the Tribe sharing the left side of the infield, Lowell was raised devoutly Roman Catholic and attended Christopher Columbus High School in Miami.
So while we would gladly claim a World Series MVP with an inspiring comeback story, there is simply no Jewish heritage lurking in the Lowell family tree. He remains a bona fide hero in Boston and Miami, just not on Yom Kippur.