El Santo
For nearly five decades, Rodolfo Guzmán Huerta never showed his face in public without his signature silver mask. He wore it to restaurants, on airplanes, and throughout dozens of gloriously campy B-movies where he tackled vampires, werewolves, mummies, and extraterrestrial invaders. He was more than a luchador; El Santo ("The Saint") was a mythic Mexican superhero, a symbol of justice, and a folk hero so devoted to his gimmick that he was ultimately buried in the mask.
With a secret identity guarded more fiercely than the location of the Ark of the Covenant, could there be a hidden Jewish past beneath the silver lamé? Alas, no. Born in Tulancingo, Hidalgo, Guzmán was devoutly Catholic—as you might guess from a man whose chosen moniker translates to "The Saint" and who frequently used crucifixes and holy water to dispatch movie monsters between suplexes.
If Judaism had masked superheroes battling bloodsucking fiends in mid-century cinema, we'd certainly claim them. Imagine the theological debates in the ring, or defeating Dracula with a well-aimed bar mitzvah fountain pen. Unfortunately, El Santo belonged entirely to the traditions of Mexican Catholicism and lucha libre. An absolute legend of the squared circle and the silver screen, just not our tribe.