Tamás Vásáry
Tamás Vásáry was born in Debrecen, Hungary, to a prominent Calvinist family. His maternal grandfather was Baltazár Dezső, a famed Reformed Church bishop, while his father’s side hailed from aristocratic stock. In Hungary, being born into that lineage usually means you're as far from the synagogue as humanly possible, and indeed, Vásáry was raised entirely within the Christian tradition.
Naturally, possessing preternatural musical genius at age eight and making your debut under Ernő Dohnányi tends to trigger the Jewish radar. Classical music in Central Europe was so deeply intertwined with Jewish talent that whenever a Hungarian kid sits down at a piano and plays Chopin with exquisite, soul-stirring perfection, assumptions are inevitably made. But sometimes a prodigy is just a regular Protestant who practiced ten hours a day.
Vásáry went on to flee Soviet-dominated Hungary in 1956, settling in the West and building an illustrious career as a Deutsche Grammophon darling and a celebrated conductor, notably with the English Chamber Orchestra and the Bournemouth Sinfonietta. An undisputed master of the keys, an officer of musical culture, and an all-around maestro. Just without an ounce of Jewish heritage to claim.