Walter Johnson
If you're assembling an all-time baseball rotation, Walter "The Big Train" Johnson is pretty much mandatory. Over 21 seasons with the perpetually mediocre Washington Senators, Johnson racked up 417 wins, an untouchable 110 shutouts, and a fastball so terrifying it prompted Ty Cobb to admit he practically gave up trying to hit it. He was a gentle giant who refused to throw inside because he was genuinely afraid of killing opposing batters. What a mensch, right?
Well, culturally perhaps, but genealogically, not in the slightest. Born on a farm in Humboldt, Kansas, Johnson was of Swedish and Scots-Irish descent. His grandfather had settled in Kansas before the Civil War, and the closest Walter ever got to a synagogue was probably driving past one in downtown Washington, D.C., on his way to Griffith Stadium.
Instead, baseball fans seeking legendary Jewish pitching prowess must look elsewhere—namely, Sandy Koufax and Hank Greenberg's occasional musings about throwing strikes. Johnson retired to a dairy farm in Maryland and later served as a county commissioner, about as far removed from the tribe as a legendary sidearmer could possibly get.
So while we would love to claim the man who held the all-time strikeout record for over half a century, the history books remain stubbornly non-Jewish. He remains baseball royalty, but strictly of the Gentile variety.